Contract chains and outsourcing – The assumptions and limits of corporate fragmentation in view of the risks of organized irresponsibility.

In a new column in JOTA, Ana Frazão discusses how the duty of diligence extends to commercial partners and reaches the participants of the production chain

It is possible to outsource activities, but not responsibilities. Based on this formulation, extracted from the Supreme Court judgment on outsourcing of end-activities, Ana Frazão examines to what extent the internal distribution of risks among members of a contractual chain may affect the imputation of responsibilities to vulnerable third parties — consumers, workers and victims of environmental damage. Outside Consumer Law, the author recalls, there is no legal rule of solidarity responsibility among the members of the chain, which makes it necessary to find other grounds of accountability.

The proposed key lies in the procedural dimension that the duty of diligence has assumed, to the point of requiring care both in the choice and in the monitoring of commercial partners: "it is not enough to know whether the partner provides a good service or delivers a good product; it is essential to know how he provides such service or manufactures his product". The column runs through ADI 5465, a CVM precedent on work similar to slavery in a hired company and the European directive establishing the corporate due diligence duty, to conclude that solutions should balance decision-making capacity, appropriation of economic benefits and effective assumption of risks, avoiding "the creation of economic efficiencies through improper transfer of social costs".

📄 Read the full column in the JOTA: https://www.jota.info/opiniao-e-analysis/columns/company-and-market/contractual-and-possible-to-outsourcing-activities-without-taking-responsibilities

The 50 years of the S.A. Law – The transformations of the power structure of societies by actions and the challenges they impose.

In a new column in JOTA, Ana Frazon discusses how intermediate positions of power challenge dichotomy between controller and minority

If society by actions is one of the great instruments of capitalism, understanding its real structure is the key to understanding the very organization of capital and economic power. In the year the law of the S.A. turns fifty, Ana Frazão revisits what she considers her great innovation — recognizing the controller as an instance of power that transcends the formal organs of the company — and shows how this step put Corporate Law at the forefront of Private Law, inaugurating a view of Private Law not as a neutral technique, but as an instrument of consolidation or modification of power relations.

Five decades later, the author argues, the challenge became more complex. The column runs through the intermediate positions that escape the controller-minoritary dichotomy — significant influence, benchmark shareholders, business groups, external control and interlocking directors — and the role of connector agents or gatekeepers, such as consulting, auditing, think tanks and proxy advisor firms. The final warning is direct: "the flexibility of the business organization cannot become an instrument of organized irresponsibility, creating asymmetries between decision-making capacity, appropriation of economic benefits and effective assumption of the corresponding risks".

📄 Read the full column in the JOTA: https://www.jota.info/opiniao-e-analysis/columns/company-and-market/power-structure-of-the-associations

Chain of consumption and solidarity responsibility – The limits of accountability of banks, carriers and digital platforms.

In a new column in JOTA, Ana Frazão analyzes two recent STJ precedents and warns against generalizations that can shield digital platforms

Not every agent who maintains economic relations with the supplier integrates the consumer chain. Starting from the judgment of the Divergence Embarks in Agravo in REsp 2,422,743, in which the STJ removed bank liability for delay in the delivery of property, Ana Frazon examines the criterion of functional integration to the chain — also applied in the precedent which excluded the liability of the carrier in the case of adulterated milk. For Minister Isabel Gallotti, rapporteur of the first case, the mere supervision of the work by the financial agent does not allow to assume that the bank acts as executive of the enterprise.

The column warns, however, to the risk of excessive generalizations from those judged. The author argues that, "in situations where the platform assumes management and has interference on the central aspects of hiring, including pricing, there is no reason to depart from its solidarity responsibility". The conclusion is that the delimitation of the chain of consumption requires functional and substantial analysis: if it is necessary to avoid indiscriminate expansion of responsibility, it is also essential "to prevent the contractual fragmentation of business activities from being used as an instrument of removal or mitigation of the responsibilities of those who effectively organize, direct and control the supply of products and services".

📄 Read the full column in the JOTA: https://www.jota.info/opiniao-e-analyze/columns/company-and-market/who-responsive-to-consumer

Political manipulation via algorithms – What NetLab-UFRJ's new reports reveal about the performance of TikTok, Kwai and Meta in the elections.

In a new column in the JOTA, Ana Frazão discusses how the opacity of digital platforms compromises the integrity of the electoral process

The voter cannot make a rational decision if he does not have access to the facts on the basis of which he can guide his choice. Based on this premise and three recent NetLab-UFRJ reports on TikTok, Kwai and Meta, Ana Frazão argues that the problem of political manipulation by algorithms, far from being solved, worsens each election. Recommendation of contents of candidates in disagreement with the electoral norm, advertising guidelines that do not fully comply with TSE requirements and advertisements without the label of electoral propaganda, driven by irregular advertisers, are some of the findings examined in the column.

The author shows that these are not episodic occurrences, but systemic failures, which reveal a "front rule, in which the formal adoption of policies and mechanisms of transparency produces an appearance of adherence to regulatory requirements without it being translated into its full implementation". The column warns that the greatest gravity is in what we cannot know — the extent of irregularities and the real capacity of institutions to monitor them — given the risk that "the destinies of brazilian democracy are decided by a private foreign algorithmic governance".

📄 Read the full column in the JOTA: https://www.jota.info/opiniao-e-analysis/columns/company-and-market/political-way-algorithms

Ana Frazão column on Jota 01/10: Business secret and procedural secrecy – How to reconcile the protection of the secret with the right to proof and contradictory and the effectiveness of jurisdiction?

Ana Frazão discusses the limits of company secrecy in court and arbitration proceedings

New column article Constitution, Company and Market, from the portal JOTA, Professor Ana Frazão asks how reconcile the protection of business secrecy with the right to proof, contradictory and effective jurisdiction. The theme gains weight with the digital economy, in which many illicit conducts are practiced by opaque algorithms.

Business secret is not immunity

The article recognizes the importance of company secrecy to preserve the value created by economic agents and conditions of competition. But remember, if he's treated as absolute, he could become a real immunity before state or arbitral jurisdiction. According to the author, art. 206 of the Industrial Property Law itself admits the breach of secrecy in judgment, provided that there are due precautions.

Highlight Phrase:

"The secrecy of a company does not confer – and cannot confer – absolute protection on its holder in evidentiary terms."

Procedural solutions for a possible balance

The teacher proposes some paths for the judges:

  • consistent criteria for defining what business secrecy is;
  • adequate distribution of the burden of justifying secrecy and breach, including to avoid fishing expeditions;
  • granularized procedural secrecy, with versions of the documents with stripes;
  • confidentiality clubs, in which only a few lawyers, experts and the judge access the complete proof;
  • date rooms.

The text cites decisions of the STJ, such as the Take Off case and the figure of the digital inventor. It also warns of the risks of absolute protection of the source code in the digital economy.

Highlight Phrase:

"If the protection of the code is absolute, the agents who use it will have a true immunity to violate other people's rights without those affected being able to prove the violation."

The article reinforces Ana Frazon's contribution to the debate on business law, competition and proceedings.

🔗 Read the full article in JOTA: https://www.jota.info/opiniao-e-analysis/columns/company-and-market/company-and-process secret

Ana Frazão's column on the 24/09 Jota: Right of access to the digital world – New outlines of the discussion due to technological advances.

Ana Frazão analyzes the new contours of the right of access in the digital world

In article published on September 24, 2026 in the column Constitution, Company and Market, from the portal JOTA, Professor Ana Frazão discusses how technological advances are transforming the debate on the right of access. This subject has traditionally been dealt with by competitive and regulatory law based on the doctrine of essential facilities.

From physical bottlenecks to digital ecosystems

In the article, the teacher shows that competitive bottlenecks are no longer limited to physical infrastructure. They include platforms, operating systems, APIs, app stores, data sets, means of payment, cloud infrastructure and ranking. In this scenario, it's not enough to be on the platform. Positioning and visibility are decisive for rivalry.

Highlighted phrase:

"In the digital economy, the focus of the discussion ceases to be on those who own the infrastructure and move to those who have the governance of the technological ecosystem."

Data, interoperability and algorithmic governance

The text also addresses:

  • the debate on considering personal data as essential facilities;
  • the practical challenges of data sharing;
  • the role of interoperability;
  • the risks of lack of transparency in algorithmic governance, especially when the infrastructure holder competes with the users themselves.

The author also deals with the regulation ex antewith Digital Markets Act European and PL 4675/2025, known as "Brazilian DMA". It also mentions the new challenges brought by artificial intelligence and the green transition.

"It seems that we need a regulatory package that goes beyond competitive issues, and even with regard to them, it may require other approaches than that offered by traditional antitrust control of conduct."

The article reinforces Ana Frazon's contribution to the debate on competition, regulation and digital economy.

🔗 Read the full article in JOTA: https://www.jota.info/opiniao-e-analysis/columns/company-and-market/access-right-in-the-world-digital

Ana Frazão column in Jota 10/09: Corporate civil liability in the face of uncertainties – The relationship between the precautionary principle and the duty of care.

Following the previous column, Ana Frazão analyzes the relationship between the precautionary principle and the duty of care. The article discusses the challenges of extending civil liability to damages that escape the usual notions of risk — frequent scenario in Environmental Law and regulation of artificial intelligence — and presents, from the original wording of PL 2338/23, an intermediate criterion: responsibility for uncertainties that can already be considered based on incipient, incomplete or speculative evidence.

Link: Corporate civil liability in the face of uncertainties – The relationship between the precautionary principle and the duty of care.

Ana Frazão's column in the 3/09 Jota: Corporate civil responsibility and duty of care – Progressively, the duty of care assumes the role of the guiding thread of subjective civil responsibility as the objective.

In her column in JOTA, Ana Frazão discusses the distinction between subjective and objective civil responsibility and shows that the duty of care has become a common element in both modalities. The article examines why the risk-based liability does not dispense with the analysis of the entrepreneur's conduct, points the reservations to the so-called comprehensive risk and deals with the relevance of predictability and the calculation of the damage for the delimitation of the risk itself. Link: https://www.jota.info/opiniao-e-analysis/columns/company-and-market/business-civil liability-and-care https://www.jota.info/opiniao-e-analysis/columns/company-and-market/business-civil liability-and-care