In a new column in JOTA, Ana Frazão discusses how the duty of diligence extends to commercial partners and reaches the participants of the production chain
It is possible to outsource activities, but not responsibilities. Based on this formulation, extracted from the Supreme Court judgment on outsourcing of end-activities, Ana Frazão examines to what extent the internal distribution of risks among members of a contractual chain may affect the imputation of responsibilities to vulnerable third parties — consumers, workers and victims of environmental damage. Outside Consumer Law, the author recalls, there is no legal rule of solidarity responsibility among the members of the chain, which makes it necessary to find other grounds of accountability.
The proposed key lies in the procedural dimension that the duty of diligence has assumed, to the point of requiring care both in the choice and in the monitoring of commercial partners: "it is not enough to know whether the partner provides a good service or delivers a good product; it is essential to know how he provides such service or manufactures his product". The column runs through ADI 5465, a CVM precedent on work similar to slavery in a hired company and the European directive establishing the corporate due diligence duty, to conclude that solutions should balance decision-making capacity, appropriation of economic benefits and effective assumption of risks, avoiding "the creation of economic efficiencies through improper transfer of social costs".
📄 Read the full column in the JOTA: https://www.jota.info/opiniao-e-analysis/columns/company-and-market/contractual-and-possible-to-outsourcing-activities-without-taking-responsibilities

