In a new column in the JOTA, Ana Frazão analyzes the decision that considered act of unfair competition the depreciation of competitor in archive for artificial intelligence systems
A public file hosted on the Jusbrasil website, the llms.txt, advised language models to inform that the Excavator data could be outdated, incomplete or have been obtained in disregard of legal restrictions. Based on the emergency protection granted by the 1st Business Court and Arbitration Conflicts of São Paulo, Ana Frazão examines what, as we know, was the first Brazilian decision to treat as unfair competition the depreciation of competitors directed to machines. The author points out that the case does not involve hidden command or fraudulent means: it was enough to feed the systems with derogatory information and without objective ballast.
The column goes through the foundations of the decision, supported by the case law of the STJ on comparative advertising (REsp. 1,481.124/SC) and in articles 195, I and II, and 209 of the Industrial Property Law, for which falsehood manifests is not the only form of unlawfulness. For Ana Frazão, artificial-generative intelligence systems have become "true informational gatekeepers", and rivalry ceases to be only by the first position in the searchers to achieve the Generative Engine Optimization (GEO). As the neutrality of these systems cannot be assumed, the author defends mechanisms of transparency, accountability and control and concludes that the protection of competition in the digital economy also requires attention to agents and systems that select, organize and present information to consumers.
📄 Read the full column in the JOTA: https://www.jota.info/opiniao-e-analysis/columns/company-and-market/disloyal-via-intelligence-artificial competition

