contato@professoraanafrazao.com.br

+55 (61) 3247-0650

Lawyer and Professor of Civil, Commercial and Economic Law at UnB

Legal knowledge to understand the challenges of contemporary society, acting in the intersection between law, economy, company and market.

+55 (61) 3247-0650

contato@professoraanafrazao.com.br

Follow our networks

News

PORTAL OF THE MAGISTER – Limited liability

Far from being an unjustified privilege granted to business companies, the limitation of the responsibility of the partners is an important instrument to stimulate productive investment. In fact, the perfect patrimonial separation resulting from it makes only the property of the personified society – and no longer the personal assets of the partners – answer ordinarily for the debts of the society.

By means of limited liability, the partial socialisation of the business risk is ensured, in that, in the face of the company’s patrimonial insufficiency, it will be creditors – and no longer members of limited liability – who will bear the losses. It is based on the premise that, being in everyone's interest the promotion of productive investment, it is fair and reasonable that the community as a whole can afford part of the business risk[1], ensuring aspects that are fundamental to business activity, such as legal certainty, predictability and risk calculation.

However, there are also many possibilities that the perfect patrimonial separation between society and its partners can be abused, transforming an instrument of partial socialization of business risk into an instrument of total transfer of business risk to social creditors.

This problem is especially aggravated in countries that, like Brazil, allow the use of the model of society limited by small enterprises, of a strong personal or family character – in relation to which it is difficult to have a social interest distinct from the personal and concrete interest of the partners – and still without any care regarding the formation of social capital, a value that corresponds to the contribution of the partners to the project and, in this sense, delimits the measure of the risk they are willing to take.

In fact, it is a recurrent practice in Brazilian corporate law that there are manifestly low or inconsistent social capital values with the risk to be assumed, so that, in the face of situations of asset insufficiency, the partners will be in the comfortable position of stealing responsibility for the undertaking without having ever effectively assumed a reasonable part of the risk. Hence the subcapitalisation problems[2], given that, in the face of low values, the function of share capital is completely subverted.

However, as much as it is known that social capital is not confused with social equity – this, yes, the real guarantee of creditors – it is a fact that equity insufficiency is often the result of the derisory value of social capital, a situation in which the partners do not assume the risk of the business, transferring it exclusively to the creditors of the company.

The problem increases when one realizes that the limitation of responsibility has serious consequences especially for small creditors and involuntary creditors, seen the latter as those who have never negotiated properly with society, but are creditors of it due to unlawful acts committed by it from which they were harmed.[3].

On the other hand, it is known that the big creditors, in practice, end up being protected by an "unlimited" liability, in that they have the power to bargain to surround themselves with guarantees other than the assets of society (including personal and real by the partners) or at least to consider the risk assumed for the purpose of obtaining greater advantages in the negotiations.

It is not without reason that the assumption of the economic analysis of the right that limited liability is a factor for reducing transaction costs is based on the premise that those who negotiate with a limited liability company are able to demand additional advantages as a counterpart to the higher risk they take. It does not take much deepening to realize that such reasoning only applies to creditors with bargaining power, which obviously drives away small creditors and so-called involuntary creditors.

The scenario described shows that we are facing a truly structural problem of Brazilian corporate law, which enables many injustices and distortions. And to solve the problem, the only solution that has been used is the disregard of legal personality.

It occurs that, initially confined to the hypotheses of abuse of legal personality, as provided for in Article 50 of the Civil Code, the disregard became gradually used, in several hypotheses, only in the face of the patrimonial insufficiency, and the abuse is expendable.

In fact, the so-called "minor theory"[4] it is now the rule in many fields, such as consumer law, labor law and environmental law, among others. However, such a theory in practice matters the denial of perfect patrimonial separation. As much as it is faced with small creditors or involuntary creditors, the linear application of the lower theory has perverse effects, especially in cases where the partners have adequately used limited liability and assumed their share of the business risk.

Similarly, there may be many distortions when the so-called larger theory, which requires proof of abuse, is used indiscriminately and without the proof of the deviation of purpose that should justify the accountability of the partners and administrators.

The situation becomes even more serious when one perceives that, in Brazilian law, there is no more serious reflection about the subjective effectiveness of disregarding the legal personality that, at least in cases of application of the larger theory, should preferably fall on the partners and administrators involved in the purpose deviation. However, the STJ has already decided that disregard should cover indistinctly all partners.[5].

The indiscriminate use of disregard for legal personality therefore breaks not only with the assumptions of safety and risk calculation, but even with the assumptions of justice that, in fact, are the ones that most justify its use. Although the trivialization of disregard is a reflection of the trivialization of limited responsibility, it is not always observed that the medication, depending on the dosage, can become poison.

From the moment that disregard becomes the rule, legal personality loses, in companies with limited liability partners, its effect of perfect patrimonial separation, which discourages or prevents investment and still generates high transaction costs, which will certainly be passed on to the final price of products and services. It is not without reason that some already advocate the end of limited responsibility in Brazil[6].

We have therefore come to the worst of the worlds: a world in which legal personality and limited responsibility no longer guarantee security or justice. And without any serious initiative to solve the problem structurally, we still have no hope of a solution.

 

———————————————–

[1] FRAZON, ANNA. Social function of the company: impact on civil liability of S/A controllers and administrators. Rio de Janeiro: Renovar, 2011. p. 18.

[2] See, in this sense: DINIZ, Gustavo Saad. Corporate undercapitalisation: financing and responsibility. Belo Horizonte: Forum, 2012.

[3] FRAZON, Op. cit., pp. 389-391.

[4] The standard of the 2002 diploma corresponds to what Fábio Ulhoa Coelho (Fábio Ulhoa Coelho, Course in commercial law. São Paulo: Saraiva, 2009. v. 2, p. 74) called the "greater theory of disregard", applicable as a means of restraining frauds and abuses perpetrated through the legal entity, in contrast to the minor theory, through which the patrimonial autonomy of the legal entity would be removed with the mere loss of the creditor, a distinction that the author abandoned due to the evolution of the subject in jurisprudence.

[5] It is a hypothesis of application of the larger theory, in which it was stated that "For the purposes of disregarding the legal personality, there is no distinction between the members of the limited society. Whether they are managers, administrators or minority contributors, they will all be achieved by this disregard" (STJ, 4th T., REsp. 1,250.582/MG, Rel. Min. Luis Felipe Solomon, julg. 12.4.2016, publ. DJe 31.5.2016).

[6] SALAMA, Bruno. The End of Limited Liability in Brazil: history, law and economy. São Paulo: Malheiros, 2014.

 

Ana Frazão –
Lawyer. Professor of Civil and Commercial Law at UnB. Former Adviser of CADE.

 

 

The articles published by JOTA do not necessarily reflect the opinion of the site. The texts seek to stimulate the debate on important issues for the country, always highlighting the plurality of ideas.

Official Source: https://jota.info/columns/company-and-market/limited liability-18102017.

? ? The texts, information and opinions published in this space are the full responsibility of the author. Therefore, they do not necessarily correspond to the viewpoint of the Magistrate's Portal.

 

About the author

Ana Frazão

Lawyer and Full Professor of Civil, Commercial and Economic Law at UnB. Doctor of law. Researcher in the areas of regulation, competition, company and market.

Other News

IBRAC

Ana Frazão participates in the 32nd International Seminar on Competition Defence of IBRAC

inspection-contracts-pexels-kindelmedia-7054502

Contract chains and outsourcing – The assumptions and limits of corporate fragmentation in view of the risks of organized irresponsibility.

thumbnail lg 8d47ab23-8001-4e9d-b6d5-0367b56f5ba8

Ana Frazão participates in the XIV CONJURN, in Christmas

Related news

OZgloboZ 1

Reporting The Globe with Ana Frazão: Increase in the use of artificial intelligence by lawyers and judges lights alert in the Judiciary, which debate solutions.

downloadZ1

Advance of AI raises debate on legal liability by investment decision.

download

Ana Frazão participates in the videocast Dois Pontos do Estadão and talks about Digital Platform Regulations in Brazil.

Access and listen

Two podcasts on current themes presented by Professor Ana Frazão.